At the Japan Association for Language Teaching (JALT) we
recently amended our constitution to allow members to vote via our
website. This change was the first step in an overall plan to increase
our transparency, enhance our interaction with members, and reduce or
eliminate any unnecessary work done by JALT staff and
volunteers.
In the past, whenever we had one of our constitutionally
mandated twice-yearly Ordinary General Meetings (OGMs) we had to ask
JALT members to fill out a paper ballot, sign it, and then mail it to
our administrative office. Not only did this process take a lot of
effort and dedication by our members, but it also required our chapter
officers to remind—if not cajole, plead, or beg!—members to send in the
ballots by the deadline so that we could hold an official OGM. As you
can imagine, it also took a lot of time for our staff at JALT Central
Office to send individual email notifications to all members and then
send follow-up reminders to those who had not yet turned in a ballot.
Moreover, the process was expensive. Although the ballot printing cost
was reasonable, and the ballots were sent out in conjunction with our
regular bimonthly magazine mailing, we had to pay approximately USD$1.25
per post-paid envelope that we received.
Thus, once we learned that the Tokyo Metropolitan government
would allow electronic ballots, we immediately made plans to ask members
to approve the necessary amendments to the constitution so that we
could avoid the trouble and expense of using paper ballots and ensure
that we could easily meet the requirement of having a majority of the
nearly 3,000 JALT members attend the OGM.
First, we consulted with the Tokyo NPO government office about
the substantive and procedural requirements involved in making such a
change to our constitution. Next, we asked our legal counsel to check
the proposed amendments for any potential problems in getting approval
from the NPO Office or the way we planned to implement the electronic
voting system. Once everything seemed to be in place, we prepared what
we hoped would be the last batch of paper ballots for an OGM, mailed
them out, and began to receive the filled-in ballots from members. A few
days before the OGM in November 2010, we received approval for the
amendments from the required number of members. We thus were able to
hold our OGM and pass the motions to amend the constitutions.
Hooray!
We had hoped that, with all the consultation that we did before
drafting the amendments, and all of our care in following the advice we
received from the relevant agencies and consultants, the
member-approved amendments would be swiftly approved by the NPO Office
and we would be able to use electronic voting right away. However, it
took more than a year for the changes to be approved by the Tokyo
government. As it turned out, there were no problems with our
amendments, but the NPO Office was very careful about the way the
application documents were submitted and, once they were finally
accepted for review, the amendments had to be scrutinized by several
departments in turn before being finally approved. But because it took
more than a year, we had to use paper ballots for the November 2011 OGM.
Understandably, our members found it quite confusing to be asked to
fill out a paper ballot again because they had approved online voting
one year before.
Thus, the first time we were able to use online voting was for
our June 2012 OGM. Our members greatly appreciated the chance to check
the financial statements and other important reports online and the
ability to vote on their approval with a couple of clicks on a web page.
Thus, the first step in our plan to transform JALT has been
accomplished. To continue this effort, we are now planning to move to a
web-based membership database and streamline our conference organization
system. These projects promise to reduce the amount of administrative
time our staff and volunteers need to devote to JALT work and increase
the amount of benefits that JALT members receive from belonging to our
language teaching organization.
Currently, only officers can log in to the JALT website and the
only members-only content is thus material for officers, such as
handbooks and minutes of Executive Board meetings. Our membership
database is kept at JALT Central Office, and all updates to the
database, such as registering new members and updating membership
records, is done by our staff. Our plan is to integrate our membership
database and our website so that all JALT members will be able to log in
and view useful member-only resources, update their contact
information, and interact deeply with other JALT members and JALT
itself.
Similarly, we currently have a national conference management
system that is largely managed offline. After we fully integrate the
conference system with our website and membership database, much of the
rote work our staff and volunteers do will be made obsolete. Also, we
plan to adapt the new system for use by our chapters and SIGs to help
them manage their events.
For example, almost all of our SIGs cooperate in holding an
annual conference, Pan-SIG. The 2012 Pan-SIG conference attracted nearly
300 attendees. Although this was our largest Pan-SIG yet, it is now
very clear that chapter and SIG organizers need to have basic access to
the membership database for smoothly registering attendees, accepting
payments, and generating name badges, at a minimum. Fortunately, our
preliminary discussions with a software developer who is helping us
create the specifications for our new system are very
encouraging.
Looking back, we learned two lessons from the electronic ballot
project that may seem obvious but are proving very useful as we apply
them to our work on our new initiatives: (1) don’t be shy in getting
expert advice in addition to relying on the expertise of members, and
(2) plan for all contingencies, but still expect the unexpected.
Within a year I hope to report that we have a new membership
database and management system that has transformed the way we serve our
members and the way our volunteers spend the time and energy that they
so generously dedicate to JALT.
Kevin Cleary moved to Japan from the United States in
1991 and is now associate professor of English in the International
Exchange Center of Tokyo Medical and Dental University. At TMDU he
supports international students and teaches ESP classes, primarily to
graduate students. He has written 14 ESL textbooks, mostly on
science-related topics, with various Japanese publishers. Before
becoming JALT president in 2010, he served as treasurer and membership
chair at the chapter level and director of treasury
(2008–2010). |