TESOL Globe
August 2013
TESOL Globe
Lesson Plan: Critical Thinking Through Storytelling
by Sarah Sahr

When I was teaching Grade 8 just outside of Baltimore, Maryland, USA, my school district required all English teachers to teach “The BIG 6.” We even got a poster to hang on our wall. Basically, The BIG 6 was just a new approach to critical thinking. So, as to not keep you in suspense, The BIG 6 are:

  • Predict (what can you expect?)
  • Visualize (what can you see?)  
  • Connect (how does this relate to me?)
  • Question (what does the author want?)
  • Clarify (what’s the main point?)  
  • Evaluate (now, what do I think?)

How many of you have heard of these before? Here’s a quick storytelling lesson plan to put The BIG 6 into action. 

Materials: Starter pictures (enough for each group of students), a story, The FINAL 3 handout (.docx)
Audience: All ages, all levels
Objectives: Students will be able to distinguish between the six primary reading strategies; students will demonstrate understanding of when to use each one effectively and efficiently 
Outcome: As a class, students will be able to reflect upon on a short story by providing personal insight and evaluation
Duration: One 50-minute class period

To showcase my use of The BIG 6, I’ll use the well known story, Cinderella. However, depending on your students’ age and language proficiency, you might want to use something more challenging. I’ve always wanted to use “The Hunting of the Snark” by Lewis Carroll, but haven’t found the right time or class.

Predict
Divide the class into several groups. Make sure the groups have no more than four students. Write the words: party, magic, family, dancing, curfew, and cat, on the board. Have students talk with each other about what these words might mean and how a story could be situated around them. If students are unclear of the meanings, make a teachable moment of it and have students help each other out. When ready, solicit predictions from the class.


Click image for printable PDF:
large file (2MB) suitable for enlargement

Visualize
For the sake of Cinderella, I would bring in photo cards of a beautiful dress, a pumpkin, mice, a carriage, and an angry mother. Make enough sets of cards for each group. Continuing with the predicting task, have students arrange the photos in a way the story might unfold.

Read the Story
Notice, the version of Cinderella I’ve provided a link to is very short. Short stories work best. You can read aloud and ask the students to close their eyes and visualize what is happening (but note that then this becomes a listening activity). Or, you can hand out copies of the story to the class. It’s up to you!

Continuing with “Visualize,” have students talk about the images they saw when they were listening to the story.

Connect
Ask students to think about how this story might relate to their lives. From the groups, pair students up, so that now our groups of four are partners of two. Have students discuss, in their pairs, some of the things they thought about. Lastly, have all pairs share their thoughts with the class.

Question, Clarify, and Evaluate
The last three parts of The BIG 6 are Question, Clarify, and Evaluate. I think it’s easiest to put these three together in a small handout. This table can be printed on half sheets of paper, and the sections can be adjusted with more complex tasks for higher level students. Go over each section with the class.

Question
Have students write down their thoughts on what the author is trying to say. Or, students can write down some of the questions they still have in regard to the story.

Clarify
This is a chance for students to answer each others’ questions. Also, this is a great opportunity to make sure students have found the overarching theme of the Cinderella story (even though students may not agree with each other, it’s a great talking point for the class). As a teacher, now is a good time to walk about the room and check proficiency levels. Try not to intervene. Let students carry on their conversations without much guidance.

Evaluate
This last one is easy… what did students think of the story? Many of them may already be familiar with the story, so this might be too easy in some cases. That is why choosing a different story might be best for your class. The point is to have fun with it!

Download this lesson plan (PDF)
and the handout (.docx) 

You can find past TESOL Connections lesson plans and activities in the TESOL Connections archives, or you can visit the TESOL Resource Center. From there, search Keywords “TESOL Connections,” and you will find about 20 resources by Sarah Sahr.

____________________

Sarah Sahr works at TESOL and is currently pursuing her doctorate in education administration and policy at the George Washington University. Her professional career has taken her all over the world, most notably as a Peace Corps volunteer in Ethiopia and as a traveling school teacher/administrator with Ringling Bros. and Barnum & Bailey circus. Sarah is also a certified ashtanga yoga instructor and has managed an eco-lodge in Chugchilan, Ecuador.

Creative Commons License

"Lesson Plan: Critical Thinking Through Storytelling" by Sarah Sahr for TESOL International Association is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareA like 3.0 Unported License.
Permissions beyond the scope of this license may be available at http://www.tesol.org/permissions.