 |
Without question, the world’s schoolhouse is ever changing
in its student demographics. In any city, large or small, regardless of
the country’s history or the language of schooling, teachers work with
student populations whose ways of being have been influenced by their
cultures. We know that the word culture itself is
hardly an easy term to define. There may be a tendency to oversimplify
its definition, and it is a perilous situation when this happens in
schools. Understanding the role of culture in learning takes time and
introspection on the part of the educator. Culture is about far more
than foods, how we dance, and how we dress for special occasions. Each
student is a complex individual who represents pieces of all the culture
groups with whom she or he has interacted from birth to adulthood. An
appropriate definition of culture encompasses language, religion, norms
of behavior, and numerous other factors that contribute to making each
learner’s personality and learning style distinct. Culture delimits
learning for English language learners (ELLs) regardless of their
country of origin, and also for students growing up in multilingual
nations. For example, a child born in Curacao, one of the islands of the
lower Antilles, grows up interacting in Dutch, Spanish, English, and
Papiamento. The way Curacaoan society views and values languages is
reflected in students’ accomplishments and interpersonal interactions.
During the 2 weeks that I spent on this island in the summer of 2013, I
was exposed to individuals who beautifully and easily demonstrate the
fluidity of their language repertoire. They move across languages to
efficiently communicate with tourists from the United States, Holland,
and Latin America. I heard taxi drivers speak to me in Spanish, to my
husband in English, and to the person they said hello to as they rounded
the corner in Papiamento. My lofty goal throughout the world would be
for all learners to be afforded the freedom and opportunity to use all
their languages this way within their worlds.
Competent teachers are those who explore the worlds where
students are born and nourished to adulthood. In order to prepare
interculturally savvy educators, institutions that prepare future
teachers must carefully articulate culturally sensitive philosophies of
instruction. These should acknowledge that learners be taught the
content of math, science, and other subjects from the context of the
people who made the discoveries, wrote the books, and use the
disciplinary knowledge in their daily lives. In this article, I discuss
what teacher educators can do to prepare teachers who will promote an
appreciation of cultural differences in their classrooms.
Embarking on a Voyage of Discovery
If we hope to eliminate intolerance, we must first embark all
current and future teachers on a voyage that will open their eyes to
that which is not overtly visible. We must involve them in an honest
examination of their own level of intercultural sensitivity (Bennett,
2010). The classroom ambiance begins with the teacher and how he or she
views students. An individual who can identify his or her own prejudices
will understand the arbitrary decisions that have led to his or her
personal convictions. A practical way to begin the trip is to ask future
teachers to read about the histories of their students and compare what
they learn to their own history. When we explore who we are—what we
take for granted to be the norm—and how this differs from others’
givens, we start the process of developing intercultural competence. The
discovery helps us see the reality that much of what we define as
appropriate is often no more than what we are used to seeing, doing, and
blindly accepting as appropriate. This trip must be a requirement of
all programs of teacher preparation because culturally sensitive
instruction is what provides scaffolds to learning that allow teachers
to reach all students (Gay, 2010). The voyage of exploration is the
first scaffold to enlightenment.
Creating Welcoming Classrooms
Self-esteem, self-efficacy, and pride in one’s culture and
language are all promoted by informed, supportive educators. Teachers
are the gatekeepers who open or close the doors to social justice in
schools. Competent teachers, armed with the tools to help students
succeed, highlight students’ unique traits in their curriculum in order
to give the students a sense of empowerment. When students feel
validated in the school community, they do not have trouble challenging
themselves to achieve success. Advocacy in action begins when practicing
educators and/or teacher candidates investigate who composes their
classroom culture with the start of every new school term (Nieto
& Bode, 2012). It is only when we see into the other that we can
truly understand and come to respect people whose past differs from
ours. Informed teachers become mediators between home and school. Their
classrooms highlight the value of linguistic and cultural differences.
Teachers who uncover the knowledge learners bring to school view
variations in language as the strengths that are the basis of students’
pluriliteracies.
Language diversity can be used positively or negatively, to
welcome or separate, and to rank and sort. Indeed, language represents
identity for teachers and students (Sercu, 2011). A person’s definition
of the self is inextricably linked to his or her cultural capital in
language and culture (Collins & Blot, 2003). This is why it is
important to make sure that all the languages spoken in a school
community are reflected in the classroom and school libraries. It is
essential that students see themselves and their families’ experiences
in the everyday curriculum. Also, when teachers use the students’ funds
of knowledge as the basis of classroom examples and modeling, it is
easier for the learners to access and grasp the content being
taught.
Governments and school systems cannot be permitted to determine
the languages and materials used in schooling. Teachers need the
freedom to modify core curricula so that it will make sense to the
students in their classrooms. If those outside the schoolhouse become
the sole decision makers, they will define and control the development
of learners’ identities. Students need room to explore their
multicultural multilingual identities and levels of pluriliteracy,
whether at home or at school.
The Future
Although curricula focused on intercultural sensitivity is
something that should be the norm at all levels of schooling, we have
far to go in accomplishing this. In the United States the momentum that
is precipitating change is not a voluntary movement of advocacy.
Instead, it is a reaction to the massive demographic changes in student
populations. Schools are inundated with ELLs, and teachers and
administrators do not know how to interact with and teach these
learners. Indeed, the process of curricular transformation is needed
across all groups of educators: preservice teachers, practicing
teachers, and college professors who may have previously taught with a
sole focus on content.
References
Bennett, C. (2010). Comprehensive multicultural
education: Theory and practice. Boston, MA: Allyn &
Bacon.
Collins, J., & Blot, R. (2003). Literacy and
literacies: Texts, power, and identity. Cambridge, England:
Cambridge University Press.
Gay, G. (2010). Culturally responsive teaching:
Theory, research, and practice. New York, NY: Teachers College
Press.
Nieto, S., & Bode, P. (2012). Affirming
diversity: The sociopolitical context of multicultural education. Boston, MA: Allyn & Bacon.
Sercu, L. (2011). The acquisition of intercultural competence:
Does language education help or hinder? In G. Zarate, D. Levy, &
C. Kramsch (Eds.), Handbook of multilingualism and
multiculturalism (pp. 45–50). Paris, France: Editions des
Archives Contemporaines.
Mayra C. Daniel was born in Cuba and, with her family,
emigrated to the United States at age 10. She has taught Spanish as a
foreign language at the university level and English as a second
language at the K–12 level. Currently, she prepares future and
practicing teachers to work with English language learners in the United
States. Her volunteerism takes her to Guatemala, where she engages in
professional development with practicing teachers and teacher educators. |