Honigsfeld, A., & M. G. Dove. (2010). Collaboration and co-teaching: Strategies for English learners.Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.
This book is a comprehensive guide for educators who wish to
establish a more collaborative approach to meeting the needs of English
language learners. The book’s nine chapters and supplemental research
appendix are well organized and clearly written, and contain a careful
balance of theory and practice.
Although Honigsfeld and Dove are advocates of co-teaching, they
do not promote a “one size fits all” program model. Realizing that
English language learners have different needs, and that schools have
different program models, they advocate for a collaborative approach in
which educators plan and possibly teach together to meet the needs of
their learners. In each chapter, the authors provide a brief overview of
the topic and then a vignette that brings in teachers’ voices from the
field. Realistic challenges and successes are described. They also
synthesize current research supporting their topics and describe
informal and formal collaboration practices. Next, Honigsfeld and Dove
give advice and strategic support to educators and administrators for
implementing and sustaining systematic collaboration. After summarizing
the main points of the chapter, they provide discussion questions for
teachers who are reading this book in a preservice or in-service course
or for professional development. The authors also provide a list of key
resources for further research and inquiry.
Chapter 1 provides the framework for the book, including the
rationale, purpose, and organization. Key terms and findings from
previous research on collaboration, co-teaching, and professional
learning communities are presented. In addition, the authors describe
program models being used in schools to serve English language learners
and describe current collaboration practices. In chapter 2, Honigsfeld
and Dove discuss the challenges English language learners, teachers, and
administrators face in today’s educational climate, including the
demands of student achievement and accountability, while operating under
time constraints. To respond to the needs of all stakeholders, they
call for creating teacher partnerships and moving away from isolation
and toward collaborative school cultures. Chapters 3 through 7 deal with
who, what, how, when, and where teachers collaborate. More
specifically, Chapter 3 describes stakeholders of collaboration, which
include the students, teachers, teacher assistants, administrators,
school staff, parents, and community members. Chapter 4 is an excellent
resource defining the essential components of an integrated,
collaborative program, including informal and formal practices, how to
co-plan, how to map and align curriculum, and how to co-teach. There are
many helpful tables, figures, and visual aids to support implementing
these practices and demonstrating what co-teaching models look like. In
chapter 5, the authors discuss how to collaboratively plan, instruct,
and assess students; they include templates for support. In chapter 6,
Honigsfeld and Dove recognize that lack of time is often the primary
reason collaborative efforts fail and offer ideas to schedule
collaboration and manage time. Chapter 7 informs readers of
possibilities of collaboration spaces, both physically and virtually. If
teachers are planning to co-teach, the authors provide advice on
co-teaching models, the space requirements, and suggestions to consider.
Chapter 8 looks at assessing and evaluating collaborative programs and
includes very useful figures and tables including surveys, a
collaboration log, a co-teaching self-evaluation, and checklist. Chapter
9 does not follow the same template as chapters 2 through 8. Instead
there are six authentic case studies from elementary, middle, and high
school demonstrating the multiple forms of collaboration.
Teachers enter the profession being expected to collaborate but
often without the training to effectively do so. Teacher educators need
to prepare classroom teachers of English language learners to
understand the elements of successful collaboration. This timely text is
a must-have resource for teachers, administrators, and teacher
educators. It provides research and rationale behind collaborative
practices, and then includes practical ideas for making collaboration a
reality. In this age of high-stakes accountability, it is imperative
that educators work together to meet the needs of their students;
Honigsfeld and Dove give us the road map to do so.
Angela Bell, Ph.D.,is an ELL consultant based in Colorado. She is an adjunct instructor for
the University of Colorado at Colorado Springs and for the University
of North Dakota. Her research interests include teacher collaboration
and the administrators’ role in creating a collaborative
community. |