As teacher educators, it is imperative that we take the time to
understand the diverse contexts in which teachers work and to figure
out how we can best support them as they face a myriad of challenges
beyond simply teaching the English language. Sometimes this means taking
time out from teaching to just listen. This was brought home to me time
and time again as I worked with two distinct groups of teachers this
past summer. There is so much more to teacher education than just
providing teachers with strategies, methods, and materials.
Story #1: Western North Dakota, in the United States, is
experiencing an oil boom. This has created unforeseen challenges for
school districts as thousands of workers and their families, including
English Language Learners (ELLs), flock to the remote and rural area in
search of lucrative employment opportunities; truck drivers earn over
$60 an hour and the starting wage to flip hamburgers at McDonald’s is
over $18 an hour. English proficiency is not required.
I spent a week this past June conducting teacher workshops in
this oil boom area, helping K–12 teachers better meet the needs of the
increasing numbers of ELLs enrolling in their schools. As much as these
dedicated teachers wanted to learn about ELL methods and strategies, the
one thing they really wanted was to simply talk. The teachers wanted to
share with me how difficult it is to teach in schools affected by the
oil boom and how dramatically their classrooms have changed in the past
few years. For example, many of the new oil boom families arrive in
campers because housing is expensive and in short supply in western
North Dakota; one teacher told me that out of 23 students in her class,
17 lived in campers without running water and electricity. Teachers told
me that because of the exorbitant increases in the cost of living, some
families can no longer afford basics such as milk at $6 a gallon. There
are serious teacher shortages, especially for ELL and special education
teachers. The vast majority of school bus drivers and school janitors
have quit because the schools cannot compete with salaries in the oil
fields. The teachers also shared how their small rural communities for
the first time were struggling with big city problems, such as
prostitution and illegal drugs.
The teachers were not mad or angry but simply honest in
discussing the challenges of teaching students under such circumstances.
I realized I needed to slow down the pace of the workshops to allow
these conversations to take place. I did not have many answers or
solutions for them, but I could be a good listener.
Story #2: In July and August, I worked with a completely
different group of teachers—English as a Foreign Language (EFL) teachers from
Turkey who came to study at the University of North Dakota under the
auspices of an International Research and Exchange grant. Again, I was
prepared to share with these teachers my favorite strategies, methods,
and materials, and I had much that I wanted to accomplish in a few short
weeks. However, as I shared each new idea, the teachers peppered me
with questions. “How can I use this strategy when I have over 40
students in my classroom?” “How can I get students motivated to learn
English when they do not see any need for it outside the English
classroom?” “How can I incorporate new materials and methods when I have
to follow the government curriculum?” The teachers were not resistant
to learning new ideas but were instead sincere in their questions about
how to implement the new ideas given the context and reality of their
classrooms. Again, I slowed down my teaching delivery and enjoyed the
rich discussions that emerged about the challenges of turning
instructional theory into real-life practice.
I know that for me, my job as a teacher educator is much more
rewarding when I take the time to let teachers educate me about the
realities of their classrooms and students. I can take these teachers’
stories and use them to inform not only my own teaching practice but my
work with school administrators, policymakers, and professional
associations. TESOL International is such a wonderful community for
advocacy. I believe that as teacher educators we need to listen to
teachers and advocate for them, making sure their stories are heard.
Anne Walker received her MEd in TESOL from Boston
University and her PhD in curriculum and instruction from the University
of Wisconsin-Madison, where she specialized in literacy education for
linguistically and culturally diverse students and educational policy
studies. She is an associate
professor in the Literacy and ELL Education Department of the University
of North Dakota. She is the chair of
the Teacher Education Interest Section (TEIS) of
TESOL. |