Review
Jackson, H., & Zé Amvela, E. (2007). Words,
meanings and vocabulary: An introduction to modern English
lexicology (2nd ed.). London, England & New York, NY:
Continuum International Publishing Group.
A language teacher’s library is generally stocked with
textbooks and reference books on a wide variety of subjects, but we can
always find space for one more title. I’d like to suggest Words, Meanings and Vocabulary: An Introduction to Modern
English Lexicology, by Howard Jackson and Etienne Zé Amvela,
as a worthy candidate for your bookshelf. This compact book (216 pages,
plus a key to exercises, list of references, glossary, and index)
provides a concise overview of the fascinating field of lexicology, “a
rather neglected pursuit in English over recent years” (p.
xi).
I should begin by mentioning that this book is indeed an
introduction to, rather than a comprehensive treatment of, the study of
words and vocabulary. Furthermore, it should be approached as a
reference rather than as a potential textbook to be used in ESL/EFL
classrooms. The real value of Words, Meanings and
Vocabulary, as I see it, is as a well-organized handbook that
introduces the reader to the surprising breadth of the field in eight
short chapters. Far more than just an inventory of affixes, the book
examines the origins and formations of words (chapter 2); several
notions of “word” (chapter 3); different types of word formation
(chapter 4); word relations such as synonyms, antonyms, and hyponyms
(chapter 5); and varieties of usage, such as national, regional,
professional, and subcultural (chapter 6). The seventh chapter focuses
on resources: investigating vocabulary, discussing resources and
analytical tools, and describing the emerging field of corpus
linguistics. The closing chapter enters into the related, though
decidedly distinct, field of lexicography, “the writing or compilation
of dictionaries” (p. 2) and the scope of decision-making (and
controversies!) that goes into compiling and updating dictionaries. In
sum, Words, Meanings and Vocabulary is a rather
quick and intriguing read for anyone interested in English
words.
Each chapter shares a similar organizational sequence. It opens
with a “chapter overview” and a list of the topics, followed by a brief
set of bullet points that enumerate the objectives of the chapter. The
content of each chapter is broken down into three to six topics, each
with one or more sections (containing definitions of key terms along
with several examples to guide the reader), and a short summary to
conclude each chapter. Interspersed throughout each chapter are short
exercises, designed to reinforce key concepts reflectively rather than
with typical cloze or objective activities. There is an answer key at
the end with short but clear explanations for each exercise.
Words, Meanings and Vocabulary is
well-researched (I tallied 155 titles in the reference section) and does
a fine job of balancing theory with practical information. The writing
style is clear and accessible, with short and fairly nontechnical
definitions. The authors have done a very nice job of including copious
data that provide excellent illustrations to support each of their
points. To illustrate, in the section on word borrowings, they have
included examples from many regions of the world, such as “Romance loans
other than from French,” “Loans from the East,” “Loans from other
sources” (pp. 47–49). In addition, they are careful to point out when a
word has entered English via another language; “polka
came via French in the nineteenth century from Czech” (p.
49).
As I’ve already stated, this is not a book that an ESL/EFL
teacher would use as a student text. It does not offer hints on how to
introduce or practice vocabulary. Instead, this is a reference that
teachers can use when thinking about the many dimensions of
words.
The book under review is the second edition, published in 2007,
so there have been some updates since it was first published in 2000.
The section on electronic resources introduces the reader to electronic
dictionaries and text corpora; because these are both rapidly expanding
areas, some of the information will necessarily be a bit dated (the fact
of which the authors seem well aware). Likewise, under the heading of
“sub-cultures” is the section entitled “CB talk” (pp. 158–159), which
may or may not strike a chord with many readers. However, as is the case
with the entire text, this is an introduction to lexicology, and it is
quite easy for a teacher to research the most recent developments in
corpus linguistics and/or apply concepts from the book to new linguistic
domains. The authors have provided the framework of the field, and the
text invites the reader to pursue each topic independently and in
greater depth.
Words, Meanings and Vocabulary is a valuable
addition to my professional library and will be one I will consult
frequently as I prepare my own classes.
Dennis Bricault is professor of Spanish and director
of ESL programs at North Park University, Chicago. His research
interests include materials development for upper-division grammar
courses in both Spanish and English. |