Baurain, B. (2015). Religious faith and teacher
knowledge in English language teaching. New Castle upon Tyne,
UK: Cambridge Scholars Publishing.
Religious faith in the English language classroom is not a new
issue to international organizations that support and send teachers of
English to speakers of other languages (ESOL) around the world.
Unfortunately, there seems to be a lot of misunderstanding and
miscommunication among professionals regarding the nature and practice
of those teachers, specifically Christian teachers, who actively and
purposefully live out their spiritual beliefs in their teaching
contexts. Religious Faith and Teacher Knowledge in English
Language Teaching is Baurain’s ongoing contribution to this
conversation. Based on interviews, qualitative methods, and instrumental
case studies, the author carefully develops a framework for evaluating
the influence that personal religious beliefs have on one’s professional
teacher knowledge. The goal of Baurain’s study is a deeper
understanding of the permeation or diffusion of personal religious
beliefs throughout teacher knowledge and TESOL professionalism (p. 75).
The essential question of the study is: How do overseas Christian ESOL
teachers describe putting their religious beliefs into practice in their
profession?
The book begins with a summary of each chapter, introducing the
reader to not only the organization of the research project but also
the conflict within the TESOL community regarding the issue of
teacher-beliefs and how they affect relationships, identity, classroom
decisions, and pedagogy in general. Baurain argues for the inclusion of
personal religious beliefs alongside teacher beliefs or teacher
knowledge in language education (p. 17). Citing Borg (2003), Baurain
describes teachers as “active, thinking decision-makers who make
instructional choices by drawing on complex, practically-oriented,
personalized, and context-sensitive networks of knowledge, thoughts, and
beliefs” (p. 81). Baurain goes to great lengths in Chapter 1 to set the
stage for this discussion by defining important terms and providing
background through his extensive and relevant review of available
literature. As a Christian, this reviewer found the literature review to
be extremely significant and an excellent resource for future
reference.
Chapter 2 is an overview of the qualitative study itself. The
author describes the participants, the means and methods used, and the
study’s significance. The responding teacher-participants were teaching
in Southeast Asia at the time of the study. Their experience as English
language teachers ranged from first year novice to an experienced 7-year
teacher. All teachers were TESOL certificate graduates.
The third chapter summarizes the themes that emerged from the
interviews and scenarios that were presented to the participants. Professionalism, relationality, and
witness were stand-out concepts that were identified in the
study and are carefully discussed and defined. The fourth chapter makes
it all very personal through the case-studies. Personal profiles of four
of the participants were chosen to describe how they live out their
faith in the practice of their profession.
Of the three major concepts that the study revealed, witness appeared most often in the author’s
cross-case comparisons. Chapter 5 dives deeply into the issues of
distinctiveness and witness, applied theology and witness, and
professionalism and witness. Baurain effectively
takes the obscure and often confusing idea of witness and breaks it down
into bite-sized chunks, making it less daunting to the reader. The
final and sixth chapter revisits the question of this qualitative study
and makes suggestions for continued discussion. The inward nature of the
findings presents limitations to a study such as this, but it also
reinforces the complexity of the issue (p. 134). Baurain makes the case
for further research by suggesting more observations and interviews,
including more ethnographic approaches with the caveat that researchers
take care to analyze themselves as those who are collecting the data.
The book concludes with an appendix of the research protocols, an
extensive bibliography, and index.
Religious Faith and Teacher Knowledge in English
Language Teaching is based on a doctoral dissertation and
often reads like one. Nonetheless, for those who are interested in the
role of faith in the TESOL context, this short book (under 150 pages) is
a worthwhile contribution to the growing number of spiritually-oriented
resources becoming available to the TESOL community (e.g., Wong
& Mahboob, in press). As Christians and teachers of other
beliefs model and communicate their faith, students, regardless of their
specific religion, can be equipped with the language and freedom to
communicate that which is deep and dear in their own hearts. The book is
not without its flaws, but does provide more subject matter for
continued discussion, debate, and personal reflection about the role
faith plays in the English teaching community.
Janice Crouch has taught international students in
both EFL and ESL settings for the past 10 years. Her most recent
position was academic coordinator for a private intensive English
program. She is also a volunteer teacher in a large church-based English
program for refugees and immigrants. Teaching pronunciation and accent
reduction is her first love, with teaching academic reading and writing
following close behind. |