If the goal of our speaking and listening classes is for
students to become effective communicators, it is necessary to include
pronunciation in our lesson plans. Pronunciation is essential to
speaking; it doesn’t matter how good a student’s vocabulary is or how
few grammar mistakes he or she makes if the listener can’t make out what
the speaker is saying. However, the hours we have with our students are
hectic, and it may be challenging for teachers to squeeze pronunciation
into their instruction and activities. In spite of this difficulty,
there are some simple ways instructors can blend in pronunciation
practice with other elements of their curricula.
First, the five core pronunciation features (intonation,
sentence stress, thought groups, word stress, and linking and blending)
need to be learned before they can be performed. Though this explicit
instruction is necessary, it need not take a great deal of class time.
To save time and reduce workload, instructors may want to create a “grab
bag” of mini-lessons they can pull from semester after semester. For
instance, in my metaphorical “grab bag,” I have a consciousness-raising
activity; a short PowerPoint lesson; some fun, physical choral
repetitions; and tried-and-true practice activities. Thus, when a
teacher is ready to introduce a particular feature, all he or she needs
to do is pull out the mini-lesson and carve out 15 minutes of class
time.
CONVERSATION
The two core pronunciation features I associate most closely
with conversation are intonation and sentence stress. First, intonation
is vital to speaking because it carries the attitude of the speaker;
furthermore, it “has the power to reinforce, mitigate, or even undermine
the words spoken” (Wichmann, 2005, p. 229). In other words, how we say something is more powerful that what we say. Moreover, because intonation differs
from language to language, if a student reverts to the intonation of his
or her L1, he or she may be communicating an unintended message. For
this reason, it is crucial that students learn about English intonation.
Teachers can integrate this important feature into their lessons by
first having students participate in a quick awareness-raising activity.
Ask students to stand up one by one and say a sentence or two in their
native language. (If there is more than one student who speaks a given
language, you need have only one representative of that language speak.)
Draw students’ attention to the musical features of each language and
have them think about the musical differences between their language and
English. Then, teachers can give a brief mini-lecture about the
characteristics of intonation in English. Once the students understand
the basics of English intonation, the teacher can begin to include
choral repetition in dialogue practice. For instance, if students are
reading a conversation, the teacher can have them chorally repeat a few
lines while conducting (raising and lowering their arms) or humming to
draw focus to the intonation of the dialogue.
Sentence stress is another important feature of conversation,
as “It is common for students to emphasize every word when they are
anxious to be understood. This gives the appearance of agitation or
insistence that they may not intend, and it certainly diminishes the
effectiveness of the prosodic ‘road signs’ that the listener needs”
(Gilbert, 2008, p. 14). In order to raise students’ consciousness about
sentence stress, instructors can help them to visualize the difference
between a language that gives weight to every syllable (like soldiers
marching) and English, which gives weight to the content words (like
children running). After another mini-lecture, students are ready for
practice similar to that described above. When they are reading
dialogues (or anything else, for that matter) aloud, instructors can
choose a segment for analysis by asking which words are the important
words, which words have the most meaning to the conversation. After
students have identified the stressed words, they can chorally repeat
them. A fantastic strategy for helping students to slow down on the
stressed words and speed up on the unstressed words involves clapping.
First, read only the stressed words and clap on each one. Then,
maintaining the same rhythm, insert the unstressed words. (This strategy
is demonstrated in Meyers and Holt’s Pronunciation for
Success videos (2001).) Be prepared for a lot of
laughing.
SPEECH
In many oral skills classes, students are required to give
speeches. Clearly, students need to know about intonation and sentence
stress in order to give the best speeches they can; in addition, being
able to break their stream of speech into manageable thought groups is
also an essential skill. All great speakers make use of pausing in their
presentations because it helps the listener to follow the speaker’s
ideas more easily. For a fun awareness-raising activity, teachers need
to look no further than YouTube. For serious teachers, a clip of a
speech by a political leader or activist might work better, but I love a
suggestion from a colleague to use the overly chunked language of
Michelle, the band geek from the movie American Pie.
The clip (it is possible to find a clean one, I
promise!) makes students laugh and it is incredibly easy for them to
hear the pauses. Then, after another mini-lecture, students can practice
pausing between their own thought groups. When a teacher asks a basic
question, like “What did you do this weekend?” students can write their
answers on the board (or dictate them for the teacher). Then, as a
class, decide where the sentences can be chunked. I like to draw slashes
“/” between the thought groups and make a “shik” noise as I do it, just
for added emphasis. It’s even more fun if students make a downward
chopping motion and make the noise with me as the slashes are
added.
LISTENING
One of the biggest challenges for students listening to
authentic spoken English is the way native speakers run all their words
together into one incomprehensible mass rather than treating each word
as an individual entity. Again, although the other core pronunciation
features are also important (especially sentence stress; if the students
are trying to listen to every word in English, they are working way too
hard!), there is one feature I consider to be key for listeners:
linking and blending. Quite simply, if students are aware of how native
speakers join words together, it makes their task easier. In order to
raise students’ awareness, teachers can use a visual to show how the
sounds of words change when they are linked. There is a great picture of
this in Noll’s American Accent Skills (2007) that
clearly shows how the “d” moves over to the beginning of the next word
in the phrase “hold on.” A great way to squeeze this skill into a
listening and speaking class after the mini-lecture is a dictation.
Rather than simply hand out a set of conversation questions, teachers
can dictate them to the class. Before launching into the discussion,
students can identify the links and repeat the questions after the
teacher, linking one index finger into another to show the
connections.
VOCABULARY
Many conversation classes also devote a portion of their class
time to introducing vocabulary associated with spoken English, such as
phrasal verbs and idioms, as well as vocabulary necessary for
communication on a given topic, such as vocabulary for grocery shopping.
Word stress is one of the most essential features of pronunciation in
terms of students’ intelligibility. In my (highly unscientific)
experience, if I can’t understand my students, it is most often because
of a word stress error rather than any other kind of pronunciation (or
grammar, for that matter) mistake. This is because “the stress pattern
of a polysyllabic word is a very important identifying feature of the
word. . . . We store words under stress patterns . . . and we find it
difficult to interpret an utterance in which a word is pronounced with
the wrong stress pattern―we begin to ‘look up’ possible words under this
wrong stress pattern” (Brown, 1990, p. 51, as cited by Gilbert, 2008).
Awareness-raising is most amusingly done with anecdotes of
misunderstandings resulting from incorrect word stress, of which most
English instructors have several. Once students are convinced of the
importance of word stress, a mini-lecture with lots of choral repetition
is in order. This repetition can be done with the aid of a rubber band
(Gilbert, 2008); have students pull on the rubber band when they say the
stressed syllables of vocabulary words and relax it during the
unstressed syllables. “Stretching wide, heavy, rubber bands while
practicing the lengthened vowels can provide students with a kinesthetic
focusing tool to reinforce the contrast in duration” (Gilbert, 2008, p.
38). As well, there are a lot of fun, fast warm-up activities that
students can do to both reinforce new vocabulary and practice word
stress. For instance, the card match puts students into groups easily.
The teacher prepares index cards with the word on one, the stress
pattern on another, and the definition on another. The teacher gives one
card to each student. The students stand up, walk around the room, and
try to find the other two cards in their group. Once the students have
found their “partners,” they move their books and sit together. This
way, students review their vocabulary and get new
partners to work with for the remainder of the class.
Incorporating pronunciation into our speaking and listening
classes can be daunting, but it is necessary if our students are to
become successful speakers. By devoting a little time up front, teachers
can pave the way for repeated practice in future lessons.
REFERENCES
Brown, G. (1990). Listening to spoken
English. London, England: Longman.
Gilbert, J. (2008). Teaching pronunciation: Using the prosody
pyramid. New York, NY: Cambridge University
Press.
Meyers, C., & Holt, S. (2001). Pronunciation
for success. Weston, MA: Aspen Productions.
Noll, M. (2007). American accent skills: Intonation,
reductions and word connections. Oakland, CA: Ameritalk
Press.
Wichmann, A. (2005). Please – from courtesy to appeal: The role
of intonation in the expression of attitudinal meaning. English Language and Linguistics, 9, 229-253.
Tamara Jones has been an ESL instructor for 16 years.
She has taught in Russia, Korea, England, the United States, and
Belgium. She is currently an instructor at the British School of
Brussels. Tamara holds a doctorate in education from the University of
Sheffield in the United Kingdom. |