Using Films in Class: The Best Way to Motivate ELs?
by Rick Haill
Scene one: A man and a woman, both
wearing hats, arrive at tea-time in a restaurant where a string quartet is
playing…
Scene two:
Several people of mixed nationalities arrive for work at a hotel, looking up at
a camera as they enter in order to identify themselves.
These are
brief but significant moments from two films made more than 50 years apart
(Brief Encounter in 1945 and Dirty Pretty Things in 2002)—and each can be used in class to illustrate aspects of
society and prompt a lively discussion about the nature and meaning of
change.
Cinema is an
infinitely flexible and accessible medium that can appeal to students at any
level of language ability. For many years, I taught a course entitled Modern
British Cinema and Society at a university in the United Kingdom. This was for
both native speakers and international students. My aim was to show my students
aspects of British culture and society while also motivating them to watch
closely, share their findings, exchange views, and improve their language
skills.
In my
experience, the stimulus of a good film prompts even the less proficient
language speakers to wish to contribute to the postfilm discussion. In using
film—just as when dealing with a written text—there is a range of techniques
that, given careful planning and preparation, can encourage a class to improve
all these key skills:
Transferable
Skills |
Language Skills |
- observation
- cultural awareness
- interpretation
- analysis
- cooperation
- creative
thinking
|
- listening comprehension
- vocabulary development, both passive and active
- awareness of accent varieties
- intonation as a conveyor of meaning
- expression
of opinions
|
All of these
skills can be encouraged and developed whether watching a complete feature film
or just a short clip. In this article, I’ll make suggestions about which films
you might use and share techniques I have found effective in the classroom as
well as follow-up tasks that students might complete in or out of class.
Ideas for Teaching Film
When
teaching the aforementioned course, I had the luxury of being able to show the
films a week before we actually discussed them. The students were given an
introduction to the film, a worksheet of a dozen or so questions about key
aspects of the film, plus a list of essential vocabulary (taken from the film’s
subtitles). Thus, when it came to the class seminar, most students came prepared
with ideas, opinions, answers, and more questions.
Here are a
few of the ideas and approaches (for pair and group work, to suit different
levels of language ability) that I have used in my classes and which might suit
other teaching contexts, including remotely on digital platforms. (For more
ideas, see my website, Teach
British Films.)
Using Short
Clips
First, play
the clip with no sound, and ask students the following questions:
-
What
is the relationship between the characters? Where are they? What might they be
saying?
-
How many different shots or
camera movements are used in this scene?
-
What is the mood of the
characters in the clip? How can you tell?
Second, play
the clip with sound, and ask the following:
-
What language are the
characters speaking? In which country does this scene take place? Any
clues?
-
Why do you think music was
(or wasn’t) used to accompany this scene? If used, was it effective?
How?
-
What is the attitude of the
characters toward each other in this scene? Positive or negative? How can you
tell?
-
Where do you think this
scene comes in the whole structure of the film? What might precede—or
follow—this scene?
For added
language focus in these discussions, you may choose to highlight sentence structure
or intonation patterns, specific lexical items, or features of register and
appropriacy.
Using Full-Length
Feature Films
After
viewing the full film, have students complete any of the following activities
in writing, in class:
-
Create a table with a
column for each main character. Fill in the table with each character’s good
and bad actions or attitudes.
-
Write a paragraph: If you
could introduce another character into the film, who would it be? Give reasons
for your choice.
-
Write an angry or
appreciative letter or email from one character to another.
-
Imagine you are the main
character’s boss: Write a letter of reference for them.
The following
prompts are great for discussion in pairs or small groups.
-
What for you is the key
scene in the film? Why is it important, do you think?
-
Do
the filmmakers show their own point of view on the topic
or theme of the film? If so, how?
-
Can you think of a
better—or alternative—title for the film?
-
What is film’s overall
“message” for us, the audience, do you think?
-
Does the story proceed in a
linear way or are there jumps forward or flashbacks? If so, why are these
used?
In the
preceding tasks, more holistic skills are required: general comprehension of
story and character, interpretation of actions and motives, and imaginative
thinking. Relevant language focus might target the clear expression of opinions
and the relevant structures and phrases to enable this, such as “in my view…”,
“Yes, but why then did …?”, or “I totally disagree!”
Try the
following development activities for group tasks or as assignments for
homework:
-
Discuss how the main
characters’ lives might develop after the end of the film.
-
Write a journal entry by
the main character looking back on the events portrayed in the film.
-
Hold a class debate based
on a main theme from the film: for or against, for example, the monarchy, space
exploration, or euthanasia.
-
Work on specialised or
idiomatic vocabulary from the film, for example, from the field of politics,
sport, or cooking.
-
Using short quotes taken
from reviews of the film, rebut or agree with the critics’ views, adding your
own written review.
-
Design
a (better) poster for the film.
This last
set of activities again encourages students to think outside the box, to
analyse, discuss, and deploy a full range of language skills in working
collaboratively on tasks in pairs or groups.
Choosing the Right Films
Of course,
any number of films might be chosen to stimulate interest, a lively discussion,
and creativity among your students. Much will depend on what you wish to
achieve: whether to work on specific language items, to encourage students to
look at aspects of their own country, or to show them a film made elsewhere in
the world that reveals a different culture to their own and with different (or
maybe common?) attitudes and emphases.
Here are
just a few examples of films (British, given the nature of the course I taught)
that I have used. My criteria in choosing them were
-
quality (well received by
critics—and I liked them too!);
-
showing in a dramatic and
engaging way aspects of contemporary British life, history, or
culture;
-
appeal to a young audience
in relation to the films’ themes or content; and
-
scope for development in
terms of follow-up questions, group tasks, and spin-off activities.
I make no
apology for the age of some of these films: Quality is what counts!
In Conclusion
Films are a
rich source of material, whether you are seeking to increase students’
vocabulary; develop their listening; improve observational skills; or arouse
their interest in the culture, society, and history of a country. Through their
dramatic vividness, films have a special ability to communicate ideas and to
move us. Though texts can achieve this through stimulating the reader’s
imagination, films convey their message more immediately through imagery and
composition, as well as language.
So, if you
have the chance to introduce films as a regular part your syllabus—or even if
you wish only to use the occasional full-length film or just a short clip, then
there is pleasure ahead—both for the student and the teacher! And if you’re
short of ideas, then here is a short collection of available film-based
material:
Useful
Sources
Rick
Haill lectured for many years at Oxford
Brookes University, where he taught language teaching methodology, study
skills, and British Studies. Before that, he taught for the British Council in
France, Croatia, Egypt, and Singapore. Since his retirement as Professor
Emeritus, he has been working on his website for teachers worldwide: www.teachbritishfilms.com.
His aim, as you may deduce from this article, is to encourage teachers to use
films in and out of class!